Carfagna's Ristorante Menu

Welcome to Carfagna's Ristorante, a culinary gem in Columbus, combining authentic Italian flavors with a warm atmosphere. Located at 1440 Gemini Pl, this Italian restaurant prides itself on a diverse menu that caters to every taste.

• Pan Pizza: Choose from mouthwatering options like the 1/2 Pan BYO or the indulgent Full Pan with Carmine Vodka Sauce, each crafted with a perfect house cheese blend.
• Antipasti Highlights: Begin your meal with their renowned Meatball Trio, or savor the fresh Carfagna Bruschetta, bursting with the flavors of tomato and basil.
• Family Feature: Ideal for sharing, the customized Family Pizza/Pasta Combo delivers comfort and joy right to your dining table.

Whether you’re here for a family gathering or a casual evening out, Carfagna's ensures a memorable dining experience with their flavorful offerings and inviting service. Don't miss out on their incredible happy hour deals!

Desserts

• Raspberry Almond

  US$8.40

• Cannoli

  Authentic made with sweet ricotta cream topped with chocolate chips.

  US$7.20

• Lemon Bomba

  Lemon Bomb served with Raspberry Coulis

  US$16.80

• Tiramisu

  Mascarpone cheese and lady fingers dipped in sweetened espresso and topped with cocoa.

  US$7.20

Kids Menu

• Kids Cheese Pizza

  US$9.60

• Kids Spaghetti

  US$9.60

• Kids Chips

  US$3.60

• Kids Spaghetti + Meatball

  US$10.80

• Kids Gluten Free Pizza

  US$10.80

• Kid Cheese Ravioli

  US$9.60

• Kids French Fries

  US$3.60

• Kids Fettuccine

  US$9.60

• Kids Pepperoni Pizza

  US$10.80

• Kids Chicken Fingers+Fries

  US$9.60

Food Truck

• Italian Sausage Sandwich

  US$10.80

• Cannoli

  US$6.00

• Meatball Sub

  US$10.80

• Bottled Water

  US$1.20

• Italian Sub

  US$10.80

Stromboli

• Build Your Own Stromboli (Regular)

  US$18.00

• CARFAGNAS Stromboli (Regular)

  Salami, capicollo, tomato, banana peppers

  US$22.20

Insalata

• Side House

  Mixed Greens, Baby Heirloom Tomatoes, Cucumber, Red Onion, House Cheese Blend, Croutons

  US$6.00

• Italian Cobb

  Mixed Greens, Gorgonzola, Red Onion, Banana Peppers, Heirloom Tomatoes, Grilled Chicken, Pancetta and Hard-Boiled Egg

  US$21.60

• Side Caesar

  Romaine Lettuce, House Caesar Dressing, Parmesan Cheese, Croutons

  US$7.20

• Burrata Caprese

  Fresh Burrata Cheese, Bed of Arugula, Baby Heirloom Tomatoes, Pesto Drizzle and Balsamic Glaze

  US$19.20

• Full Caesar Salad

  Romaine Lettuce, House Caesar Dressing, Parmesan Cheese, Croutons

  US$13.20

• Full House Salad

  Mixed Greens, Baby Heirloom Tomatoes, Cucumber, Red Onion, House Cheese Blend, Croutons

  US$12.60

Pan Pizza

• 1/2 Pan BYO

  US$18.00

• Full Pan BYO

  US$28.80

• Full Pan The Carmine

  Vodka Sauce, House Cheese Blend and Pesto

  US$32.40

• 1/2 Pan Dino's Bambino

  Pizza Sauce, House Cheese Blend, Sliced Carfagna's Meatballs, Spinach and Calabrian Chili Oil

  US$18.00

• 1/2 Pan The Carmine

  Vodka Sauce, House Cheese Blend and Pesto

  US$18.00

• Full Pan Dino's Bambino

  Pizza Sauce, House Cheese Blend, Sliced Carfagna's Meatballs, Spinach and Calabrian Chili Oil

  US$31.20

Sandwiches

• Italian Sub

  Salami, capicollo ham, spicy pepperoni, and provolone cheese grilled and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, red onion and banana peppers. served with a drizzle of our house italian dressing on a grilled italian sub bun.

  US$22.50

• Italian Beef Sandwich

  Thinly Sliced Prime Rib and Giardiniera served on a Baguette, side of Au Jus and House Kettle Chips

  US$24.90

• Chicken Parm Sandwich

  Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Marinara Sauce, House Cheese Blend served on Ciabatta with House Kettel Chips

  US$20.10

• Meatball Sub

  Four of our large famous recipe meatballs smothered with our homemade marinara and topped with provolone cheese. served on a grilled italian sub bun.

  US$23.70

Antipasti

• Meatball Trio

  (3) Famous Carfagna's Meatballs served with Marinara and Romano Cheese

  US$12.00

• Carfagna Bruschetta

  Ciabatta with Tomato, Basil, Onion, Fresh Mozzarella and Balsamic Reduction

  US$13.20

• Youngstown Stuffed Peppers

  Fresh Banana Peppers Stuffed with House made Grandpa Sausage, Romano Cheese and Marina Sauce

  US$14.40

• Italian Grilled Wings

  10 Fire Grilled Chicken Wings with Garlic Butter, Parmesan Cheese and Charred Lemon Wheel

  US$16.80

• Provolone Wedges

  Crispy Provolone Wedges served with Marina Sauce

  US$13.20

• Calamari

  Red Pepper, Carrot, Banana Pepper, Artichoke Hearts over House Marinara

  US$21.00

• Arancini

  Crispy Cheesy Risotto served with Pesto and Calabrian Chili Oil

  US$12.00

• Spinach Alfredo Dip

  Served with Crispy Pita Wedges

  US$12.00

Thin Crust Pizza

• 11" Bella Bianca

  Garlic Olive Oil, House Cheese Blend, Sliced Tomatoes, Fresh Basil

  US$18.00

• 14" Zia Giulia's Margherita

  Pizza Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Tomato and Basil

  US$26.40

• 11" Zia Giulia's Margherita

  Pizza Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Tomato and Basil

  US$20.40

• 11" Sally Boy's Prosciutto Pizza

  Garlic Olive Oil, House Cheese Blend topped with Prosciutto, Arugula, Shaved Parmesan and a Balsamic Reduction

  US$21.60

• 14" Sally Boy's Prosciutto Pizza

  Garlic Olive Oil, House Cheese Blend topped with Prosciutto, Arugula, Shaved Parmesan and Balsamic Reduction

  US$28.80

• 11" Sammy The Bull

  Pizza Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage Crumbles, Caramelized Onions

  US$20.40

• 11" Lucky Luciano

  Garlic, Olive Oil, Caramelized Onions, Sauteed Mushrooms, Goat Cheese, House Cheese Blend and Truffle Oil

  US$22.80

• 11" Build Your Own Pizza

  US$15.00

• 14" Bella Bianca

  Garlic Olive Oil, House Cheese Blend, Sliced Tomatoes, Fresh Basil

  US$21.60

• 14" Big D's House

  Pizza Sauce, House Cheese Blend, Pepperoni, Sausage Crumbles, Sauteed Mushrooms, Onions, Banana Peppers

  US$28.80

• 14" Lucky Luciano

  Garlic, Olive Oil, Caramelized Onions, Sauteed Mushrooms, Goat Cheese, House Cheese Blend and Truffle Oil

  US$30.00

• 14" Sammy The Bull

  Pizza Sauce, House Cheese Blend, Pepperoni, Sausage Crumbles, Caramelized Onions

  US$27.60

• 11" Big D's House

  Pizza Sauce, House Cheese Blend, Pepperoni, Sausage Crumbles, Sauteed Mushrooms, Onions and Banana Peppers

  US$21.60

• 10" Gluten Free BYO

  US$15.60

• 14" Build Your Own Pizza

  US$19.20

• 14" Cheese

  US$19.20

• 11" Cheese

  US$15.00

• 11" Pepperoni

  US$17.10

• 14" Pepperoni

  US$21.90

Family Feature

• Family Pizza/Pasta Combo

  Customize your own family takeout meal with one large pizza, one pasta entree, and side salad.

  US$0.00

Sauce Side Upgrades

• Side Creamy Pesto

  US$2.40

• Side Vodka Sauce

  US$2.40

• Side Creamy Pomodoro

  US$2.40

• Side Spicy Pomodoro

  US$2.40

• Side Marsala

  US$2.40

• Side Piccata

  US$2.40

• Side Arrabbiato

  US$2.40

• Side Bolognese

  US$3.60

• Side Marinara

  US$1.80

• Side Pesto

  US$2.40

Build Your Own Lunch Combo!

• Build Your Own Lunch Combo!

  US$16.80

Zuppa

• Cup

  US$4.80

• Bowl

  US$7.20

• Quart

  US$12.00

Sides

• Roasted Potatoes

  US$6.00

• Fresh Cut Fries

  US$4.80

• House Chips

  US$3.60

• Add Protein

  US$0.00

• Seasonal Vegetable

  US$7.20

• Sautéed Spinach

  US$6.00

Pastas

• Nonna's Four Cheese Manicotti

  Homemade Pasta Crepes stuffed with a Family Secret Cheese Blend topped with Marinara and Provolone Cheese

  US$30.00

• Fusilli Arrabbiata

  Fusilli Noodles, Marinara, Onion, Garlic, Red Chili Flakes

  US$20.40

• Cheese Ravioli

  Large Cheese Ravioli, Alfredo or Marinara Sauce topped with House Cheese Blend

  US$26.40

• Fusilli Bolognese

  Fusilli Pasta, Bolognese Sauce-Ground Beef-Pork Blend, Onion, Garlic, Tomato, Carrot, Basil

  US$23.40

• Spaghetti + Meatballs

  Spaghetti, Marinara Sauce, Carfagna's Home-made Meatballs!

  US$21.60

• Shrimp Scampi

  Fettucine Noodles, Sauteed Shrimp, White Wine Sauce, Baby Heirloom Tomatoes and Basil

  US$26.40

• Spaghetti And White Clam

  Clams, White Wine Butter Sauce, Baby Heirloom Tomatoes served with Crostini and Charred Lemon

  US$26.40

• Carbonara Romana

  Spaghetti, Guanciale, Egg Yolk, Garlic, Romano Cheese and Pancetta

  US$27.60

• Cod Puttenesca Feature

  US$28.80

• Gnocchi Alla Vodka

  Classic Potato Dumplings, Vodka Pomodoro Sauce

  US$25.20

• Fettuccine Alfredo

  Fettucine with Carfagna's Homemade Alfredo Sauce!

  US$19.20

• Lasagna Al Forno

  Baked Layered Lasagna Noodles, Ricotta, Bolognese Sauce, House Cheese Blend and Marinara Sauce

  US$23.40

• Meat Ravioli

  Large Ground Pork and Beef Blend Ravioli with Choice of Marinara or Alfredo Sauce

  US$26.40

• Carne Combo

  Lasagna with Marinara Sauce, Large Meat Ravioli with Alfredo Sauce, Chicken Parmesan, Carfagna's Famous Meatballs

  US$30.60

• Pasta Combo

  Lasagna with Marinara Sauce, Large Cheese Ravioli with Alfredo Sauce, Gnocchi with Creamy Pesto Sauce

  US$29.94

• Creamy Pesto Chicken

  Fettucine, Creamy Pesto Sauce, Grilled Chicken Breast

  US$26.40

• Sausage + Peppers Pasta

  Rigatelli Pasta, House made Italian Festival Sausage, Garlic Oil, Sauteed Roasted Peppers, Onions and Mushrooms

  US$19.20

• Baked Ziti

  Rigatelli Noodles, Bolognese Sauce, House Cheese Blend and Whipped Ricotta

  US$25.20

• Shrimp & Scallop Cavatelli

  Creamy Lemon Pesto Sauce, Baby Heirloom Tomatoes, Toasted Pinenuts

  US$27.60

• Spicy Creamy Chicken

  Rigatelli Noodles, Grilled Chicken served with a Creamy Pomodoro Sauce-Onion, Garlic, Tomato, Basil, Red Pepper Flake

  US$26.40

Family Classics

• Eggplant Parmigiana

  Crispy Eggplant, Spaghetti, Marinara Sauce, House Cheese Blend

  US$24.00

• Chicken Marsala

  Chicken Breast served with Fettuccine Noodles topped with a Marsala wine Sauce and Sauteed Mushrooms

  US$27.60

• Veal Marsala

  Pan Seared Veal Cutlets served with Fettucine, Sauteed Mushrooms and a Marsala Wine Sauce

  US$33.60

• Chicken Parm/Fett Alfredo

  Crispy Chicken Breast, Marinara Sauce, House Cheese Blend served with Fettucine Alfredo

  US$27.60

• Veal Piccata

  Crispy Veal Cutlet served with Spaghetti and a lemon Caper Butter Sauce

  US$33.60

• Chicken Piccata

  Crispy Chicken Breasts served with Spaghetti and a Lemon Caper Butter Sauce

  US$27.60

• Veal Parm/Fett Alfredo

  Crispy Veal Cutlet, Marinara Sauce, House Bland Cheese served with Fettucine Alfredo

  US$33.60

Sauces

• Spicy Chili Ready Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.59

• Pomodoro Basilico Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.11

• Savory Italian Sausage Sauce 32 Oz

  US$10.43

• Vodka Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.11

• Market Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.11

• Sicilian Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.11

• Puttanesca Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.11

• Mild Chilli Ready Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.59

• Organic Original Sauce 32 Oz

  US$9.59

• Buther's Blend Beef Sauce 32 Oz

  US$10.43

• Little Meatballs Sauce 32 Oz

  US$10.43

Pastas (Lunch)

• Carbonara Romana

  Spaghetti, Guanciale, Egg Yolk, Romano Cheese, Garlic and Pancetta

  US$27.60

• Fusilli Bolognese

  Ground Beef and Pork, Onion, Garlic, Tomato, Basil and Fusilli Noodles

  US$23.40

• Lasagna Al Forno

  Layered Lasagna Noodles with Ricotta, Bolognese, House Cheese Blend and Marinara

  US$23.40

• Fettuccine Alfredo

  Classic Fettucine Alfredo

  US$19.20

• Spaghetti And Meatballs

  Spaghetti, Marinara Sauce and Carfagna's Famous Meatballs

  US$21.60

• Gnocchi Alla Vodka

  Classic Potato Dumplings, Vodka Pomodoro Sauce

  US$25.20